Thank you @Eggsandwhich for recommending I play this after my month of NieR. Also a shoutout to @ptcremisi cuz he loves this game too. I'm happy to say, despite some issues I had that do hold it back from me rating it higher, I really enjoyed this game a lot.

Though tbh, at first I wasn't really enjoying it all too much. The beginning cutscene really got me interested but by the time I got to the first level in the game, I started noticing issues I had. First off, I don't think the first level is that great of an introduction. I found the level design to be too simple and it's definitely my least favorite stage in the game. That plus some other issues I had while playing, really didn't help my engagement. I found the combat just okay, it got the job done but it wasn't great. The platforming too could be a little wonky. I found the ledge grab really inconsistent (tho I got used to it later on). The figments were hard to see a lot of the time and they seemed like they'd be quite annoying. It also didn't help that I played this on my PS2 and it ran poorly a lot of the time and even rarely slowed to a crawl. That combination of things, plus the poor intro level, it just wasn't doing it for me. Also later on, you start to fight bosses. While it's cool to find out how to beat them, they're often not that fun mechanically because of the clunky combat and are usually too easy on top of that.

As I played on tho, a lot of these issues were lessened a bunch cuz I blew them out of proportion. Because of this, I learned to really love the fantastic things in this game. Probably my absolutely favorite aspect would be just the game concept as a whole. Going into people's minds is just so awesome, and they really utilize it to it's fullest. Your collectibles are absolutely brilliant. Figments of your imagination, emotional baggage, cobwebs (in your head). It's just all so good and really makes the world feel so well thought out. Like the health pickups are literally called mental health, that's amazing!

The other best thing this game has going for it are the quirky/funny moments and it's memorable cast. I couldn't even count just how many times this game made me chuckle, it's so weird and I love it. It really felt like a Cartoon Network or Nickelodeon show from the early 2000's which is great because that's the era I grew up with. Feels like the love child of Billy and Mandy and Invader Zim if I'm being real. As for the cast of characters, most of kids were whatever (tho I did like Dogen and Lili) but the main cast of Psychonauts were all great. I do wish they had more screen time, because in the 2nd half due to certain events they're mostly absent, but what we do get is great. Also, a shoutout to Raz himself, what a great protagonist. He's so quirky and sassy yet likeable.

At first I was a bit iffy on the camp setting but once I explored the overworld, I really enjoyed it. It feels a bit nostalgic for some reason, and I never even went to camp as a kid. I also think the overworld had overall better level design than the actual levels. The levels are cooler and more out there than the camp setting but the level design is more linear, while the camp is more open and explorable which is fun.

Another thing I enjoyed were the Psi badges. While I wouldn't say most of them were super fun to actually use, a lot of them were used on puzzles throughout the game and are just cool conceptually. I will say though, levitation is an absolute blast and is easily the best badge in the game. Glad you get it early on because from then on, I used it all the time.

Idk why I thought this was a kids game all this time (I probably would've loved this as a teenager) but it definitely isn't considering they cuss throughout the game and the game can get pretty dark. Seriously, some of the mental illness stuff can get pretty realistic even if there is a goofy undertone, but it's still handled with tact. The vaults are another collectable in the game and they hold some of the darkest shit I swear. Milla's hidden vault 😒. But I really love how they flesh out each character even more.

I said the figments were annoying because they're hard to see, and while that is still a criticism of mine, they weren't annoying enough to the extent I didn't want to get them all. So I went and 100%ed the game and that was mostly hassle free. Some stray figments here and there and some of the milkman's conspiracy gave me trouble but that's about it.

So overall, while the actual gameplay is usually just acceptable to subpar, the charm this game has with it's cast of characters, it's quirky humor and just the awesome concept of going into people's minds won me over. This game is flawed but really enjoyable. I'm giving this a 7.5 rn only because the sequel seems to fix the gameplay issues I had. From what I've heard, 2 starts off right where 1 ended and that's just so cool I can't wait. Anyways, on to my Secret Santa game next...Metroid Prime 2!

7.5/10

Reviewed on Dec 07, 2023


18 Comments


4 months ago

Sounds like you're gonna love Psychonauts 2
@thealexmott probably, it looks awesome

4 months ago

The second game starts after the psvr game but it’s not necessary to play. I recommend playing the vr game if you can, since it’s really cool to see the characters up close and personal. Not the best gameplay wise, but the story is good.
@alasearwax yeah I'll probably play it before 2 then, thanks!

4 months ago

What was your favorite level? Mine was Milkman Conspiracy closely followed by Lungfishopolis
@itchy_sideburns those were definitely some of my favorites. I really liked Waterloo, black velvetopia and meat circus too. 2nd half of the game definitely had the more interesting mental worlds I think

4 months ago

Just went back to play this the other week, a lot rougher than I remember as a kid but the charm was still there. You're gonna love Psychonauts 2.
@Roastybunz yeah I definitely think so too, the little I've seen of 2..it really looks fantastic!

4 months ago

I'm curious to know what your favourite level was visually, I saw you say the latter half of the game had more interesting worlds but going purely off of visuals what was your number 1?
@roastybunz tough one honestly, I loved milkman conspiracy just cuz it reminded me of mario galaxy. I loved black velvetopias whole color scheme and meat circus's creepy circus visuals were great too. If I had to give it to one, probably black velvetopia tbh.

4 months ago

Happy you liked it brother, but unfortunately I can't agree. You're right about the camp being a great hub center, the level creativity great, and some of the side characters truly stand out. But I couldn't get over the tonal inconsistency, where you go from juvenile humor to the dark shit you mentioned in your post. Not to mention the art style just didn't do it for me- I genuinely thought this was supposed to be about deformed humans when I first saw shit.
Lolll the artstyle is pretty wonky on a couple characters I'll give you that for sure

3 months ago

such a unique game
1&2 are two of the best to ever do it imo
@Poet most definitely, can't wait to play 2!

3 months ago

2 will make you raise your score for this.
@poet I was thinking it might actually

3 months ago

im so glad u loved it im really looking forward to your psychonauts 2 review
@bastardjodie thanks! I cant wait to play 2, looks awesome