Feels like it was developed by a committee. Does nothing but poorly mimic the popular shooter trends of its era. Whatever magic the series had is absent here.
Worst of the three. Hardly feels like a sequel to its predecessors, despite being the last chapter in the "trilogy". Brings little interesting to the table and is mostly forgettable. Also, Ellie deserved better.
Fantastic narrative set in an oppressive, unforgiving world. Few games elicit the emotions that this one does. The survival elements are pitch perfect.
People like to say this is where the series started to go downhill. Honestly, this is just the culmination of years of bad decisions. Very little here is worth mentioning.
Refreshing return to this world and style of gameplay. Just the right length. Whenever the gameplay runs the risk of becoming stale, they introduce something interesting. Absolutely worth playing if you like the original.