rating the franchise as a whole. fine to play mindlessly but hurt to pay any amount of real attention to. even then the story strays further and further from the original appeal of exploring recreated ancient settings and turns the attention on the dumbass end of the world plot.
a cool story to make a wiki about. a lot of concepts are pretty under baked compared to things that do similar things. probably more impressive to the average player. gameplay is simply fine, bioshock 1's gamelay but less engaging.
this game is boring as hell compared to the sequel, but even thats kinda sleepy after a while. dont feel the praises for the writing and the gameplay certainly isn't better.
a lot of bitching about the writing goes on but its hard to notice that over the unrelated yelling from your friends in the call. gameplay is better, but only marginally.
as of phase 1: massive fucking step down from his last project, legitimately fell asleep while reading with how shit this pacing gets. some good moments/interesting seeds planted for characters though, maybe it'll get better