Return of The Obra Dinn is about a missing ship that has suddenly returned with its whole crew either dead or missing. You are tasked with investigating its history through the help of a stopwatch that lets you see the exact moment of someone's death and a book where you write down the fates for each crew member.
It's pretty nicely bite-sized (about 10 hours for me) and the main game mechanic is really creative. I was worried that i would get bored or stuck after having gone through enough "snapshots" but every one of them had so much going on in it that every time i returned to one i'd always find something new (and there were so many subtle clues that i had to), and successfully pieceing parts together felt super satisfying. It's also rewarding to see the story fold out as the game progressed even if it wasn't the main enjoyment for me.
There's just something i really enjoy with indie-developers taking their limitations and turning it into an advantage. The 1-bit shader over the low-poly graphics meshed with the time period it's set in, and since every major part of the game took place in a static snapshot pretty much nothing of it was animated, yet i remained fully immersed into the scene and was actually to my advantage since i was scanning through a lot in the scene.

I just think its neat!

For the (very few) horror games I've played this has to be my favourite one, with its relatively small scope it's polished pretty much to perfection. The low-detailed, atari-esque graphics is a genius choice for the genre and make the rotoscoped cutscenes/jumpscares feel jarring in the best way. The controls and game mechanics are really simple (four moving directions + action button to exorcise) so all your focus is directed at the atmosphere and story. A couple of the boss fights took quite a few attempts to get through which brought me out of the horror for a bit but its really good at dragging you back into it afterwards.
I'm currently halfway through chapter 3, can't wait to see how they wrap this up

TLDR: those fnaf interludes WISHES they were Faith