The pinnacle of Halo. So many hours spent playing the campaign, multiplayer, and messing around in Forge.

Incredibly average. Sequel is a massive improvement.

My personal favorite COD. The campaign, multiplayer, and zombies were firing at all cylinders.

COD fatigue had hit me when this one came out. I didn't find any of the modes very interesting.

Not as good as the first but worthy of a playthrough.

Boring and overlong but with just enough camp to keep it semi-interesting.

Bland. Almost none of the spark or humor of the original but the gameplay is as tight as ever.

Could've been great but it goes on for way too long.

Painfully average. The game that made me stop preordering.

Too ambitious for its own good. Boring and undercooked.