Reviews from

in the past


Very cute game if you like MLP. Would highly recommend to all my bronies. I played this a while ago but forgot to log it.

This review contains spoilers

someone got fake messaged by jumbo josh and all i got was a fake message from a person i dont talk to anymore -__-

Juego cortito, loco y bizarro pero increible

Court mais très sympathique, Asmodeus est un génie ses pranks sont exeptionnels


It's a really chaotic experience but the concept is interesting. It takes a lot of influence from other similar games that take the premise of a game within a game to the core. It is an alright experience since neither the story or gameplay are extremely unique, even with the file browsing system. The puzzles are interesting and the levels satisfying to play (considering it's just jumping and shooting). I feel the game is a little too long for what it does.

short, fun, the ancestor to one of my favourite games. panda circus HYPE!

great story game. subversive in a non-annoying way

satan sits behind me and laughs as i keep failing all the programming puzzles

It was aight. Very similar to inscryption but not as visually appealing or engaging gameplay wise/stroy wise.

If the name "Inscryption" rings any bells, get yourself this game for $1 on any steam sale and get hyped for Pony Island 2!

I was excited to play this game, as I am a massive fan of Daniel Mullins' other game "Inscryption", but this game was unfortunately not able too pull off the same levels of intrigue or finesse as that title. Neither the 'usual' nor the subversive moments in this game were interesting to me, and the best thing I have to say about it is that it told its narrative with relative brevity.
If you were thinking of getting this game, I would strongly suggest you get Inscryption instead!

Very creative game, this Daniel Mullins guy knows how to make 'em. A steal on sale for $0.45.

pretty cool! came straight from inscryption which ended up being one of my favorite games ever to this so it was a little bit of a letdown but whatever! i think my expectations were just set too high

I didn't enjoy the core mechanics and didn't find the "YOURE IN HELL WAHH" plot interesting. Has weird pacing and stretches its concept very thin, despite its short runtime.

Pony Island em 2024 provavelmente não tem o mesmo impacto que teve em 2016, quando 4th wall breaks em jogos não eram algo tão comum ainda. Quando esse impacto é retirado, não vejo grande coisa de sobra. Muita gente não culparia o jogo, mas para mim isso é uma grande falha.

Em jogos como OneShot, 4th wall breaks são um elemento importante no design da experiência, mas servem de um modo produtivo para alimentar uma história e atmosfera que se seguram de pé. Pony Island parece ter sido feito ao contrário, onde toda a história e atmosfera estão em serviço de ser o spooky game com 4th wall breaks. Honestamente o jogo parece-me só demasiado superficial, style over substance, não há nada significativo aqui a ser dito ou feito.

Não me interpretem mal, é um jogo muito competente no seu design e a arte é fixe, e pelo menos não se prolonga desnecessariamente. Nunca estive aborrecido a jogar, mas também nunca estive muito cativado. Por falta de uma palavra melhor: é mid.


Short but fun game. Feels very basic but also still works well in todays standards.

its no inscryption but it definitely pilled me at the time

A worthy start to the Daniel Mullins canon. Very weird.

Rlly a great game, I just wish there was more to get out of the puzzles and stuff

Pretty neat game. After having played Inscryption, its fun seeing the begin of everything I loved about Inscryption. A lot of similar ideas. Also it was only 2 hours so that rules.


It's an offline dinosaur game with lasers and fourth wall breaks. I had some fun. The puzzles especially made me feel kind of smart and were pretty fun- never overstayed their welcome. It got a bit annoying at times and dragged at others, but the bit with the fake Steam message? That got me—cool fourth wall break.

Me encantan estas pequeñas joyas indie, estas historias reducidas sin búsqueda de la grandilocuencia de un triple a, mi momento favorito es cuando se rompe la 4 pared en el quiz de asmodeus

No one is on the level of devil. A really unique experience with some shocking and perplexing moments that are mired by gameplay that ends up being repetitive and unfun puzzles that might not be your thing.

Regardless, worth experiencing at least once.