BotW but better. Sadly, it came out after BotW, so we've already seen a large part of what it has to offer. If BotW didn't exist this would be a strong 4, if not a 5.
A solid Mario game with not much else going for it. In a series known for innovating on the same formula for 40 years, this just doesn't do anything special.
Absolutely beautiful experience. If ot weren't for a couple slightly obtuse clues it would probably be perfect. Haven't played it with the DLC yet, so maybe it is perfect by now.
While it's still one of the best, the amount of bugs and unfinished content at launch were extremely detrimental to my first experience(s) with it as a kid. Constant crashing. I played it a bit on PC with mods, but never finished.
Perhaps the best Zelda game ever. I actually originally played it on the Zelda Collector's disc on GC when I was a kid, but didn't even mind that it was a bit clunky. If not the best, it's at least the coolest.
I'd like to rate this lower, but I played it twice when it came out even though I didn't care much for it, so it must have something good going for it.