@conman the word on the street from what Ive seen is "honest hearts is cool because joshua graham is in it", "old world blues is reddit and cringe" "dead money is based and people only disliked it cause they're scrubs" and "lonesome road is bad because of ulysses' ranting". Personally I like all of em to a certain extent, although ive only played Dead Money once (personally, I like the setting, characters and removing your equipment, but I hate the exploding collars mechanic, imo it just turns into tedious save scumming every time your collar beeps until you find the radio or run past). I love Lonesome road for its gameplay, Old World Blues is okay and Honest Hearts is a nice foreshadowing of Pentiment, with a solid main character and setting but IMO has really dull fetch quests for the most of it