Overhated and/or misunderstood in general by a lot of RPG fans

Gameplay underrated and sometimes misunderstood; Writing rightfully hated

Underrated in general

Overhated in general

Specifically Redux
Overhated in general; I think it's a mostly good version, including the new endings, but Alex does suck I'll agree with that.

Gameplay slightly underrated

Underrated in general

Overhated in general

Underrated in general

Writing, theme-ing and RPG elements underrated
Gameplay and Presentation elements rightfully hated

Gameplay overhated; Main story maps are some of the best in the series imo, I only dislike the Gaiden maps really

wip

Overhated in general

Specifically CS1 and CS2
Overhated in general; CS3, 4 & Reverie have more character writing and story planning issues for me personally

Underrated in general

Story and vibes underrated

Slightly underrated in general

Overhated in general

Slightly overhated in general, but I'm not crazy over it either. I just don't think the atmosphere killed my pets or anything.

Overhated in general; It does what it sets out to do well enough. Most haters can't accept it's not trying to be the same experience as RE2R or RE3 OG

Same as FE Fates: Conquest
Gameplay underrated and sometimes misunderstood; Writing rightfully hated

Weirdly overhated in general; should not be considered one of the "NES black sheep sequels", it's a stronger experience than DQ1 in every way