It's pretty hard to give this game a true rating since Minecraft back then is not Minecraft now. This game has no nether update, no cave update and it's plagued with that annoying crafting feature the legacy editions have

BUT i do kinda love it

I loved experiencing the old nether, the basic caves and exploring the limited map size. It's probably nostalgia but this is Minecraft to me. The new Minecraft just doesn't feel like MINECRAFT

I like both though and I'm glad this time capsule is still around to be experienced like nothing ever changed

Again, just like the rest of Gamemills GOTY contenders, I don't think this is the fault of the developer. The game was for sure intended to be good but I imagine there was time restraints and crunch so the end product was once again mid asf

There's no collectables at all which, while amazing for a trophy hunter, fell short for practically everyone else that enjoys a collectable grind.

The story assumes you've watched the show and leaves a decent chunk of it down to little paragraphs before you start the next mission

The film grain setting is ass and idk why they would actually recommend it to be used at all and to top everything off - the combat is very bad and the game glitched on me a few times, locking me out of a trophy at one point too

not the best game in the world

I'm not going to say this is a cash grab because I feel like the devs did actually try their best. I would say that Gamemill once again decided to push the game out too early and this is the result

I quite liked the puzzles during the game, a couple per level is actually a great addition but the entire collectable clean-up is botched and would've been impossible without someone online making a spreadsheet for the chests

Also, the game is under the assumption that you've watched the show and SO much is skipped over that I decided not to pay attention to the story at all. The combat was also terrible and the lock on feature is the only saving grace to beat the spirit trials

I actually really enjoyed this. I played on veteran the entire time and some missions were pretty hard but overall, nothing compared to MW3 spec ops

The story isn't really the best but it was more or less just setting up for the trilogy rather than being a good standalone - hopefully MW2's story is better

I also don't really get the hate for Mile High Club on veteran? It's really just about narrowing down a strategy that works for you and using flash bangs to your advantage

Overall, good game but campaign isn't crazy

Overall the game is amazing but I think the story could be a tiny bit better

Everyone justifies the story being eh because RDR2 makes up for the plot holes and makes you feel for certain characters - which is fine - but RDR2 was not a thing when this game released so it's not a valid excuse

I think the story needed a bit more padding and if it were to release now, with the way rockstar has been with storytelling, this would've banged 10x harder for sure

An overpriced game for sure but 1000000% worth it for me

The game looks incredible and to have the Left Behind DLC also remade too is amazing. Everything fits so well with TLOU2 now and it's crazy to see all these characters I love actually have visible emotion

It's basically everything I wanted when it comes to a remake of TLOU but I think it was too soon lowkey

Cat game

what more could you ask for

GOTY easily and I want Stray 2 pls

A great entry into the ICO trilogy but I feel it falls short coming off the back of SOTC.

As it's own game it's amazing but I do think Team ICO/Gendesign had a bit more in them

I loved the ending though, was such a cool moment and the sunset from the tower is beautiful