All Metacritic Must-Plays
Metacritic designates a game as "Must-Play" when it achieves a Metascore of 90 or higher and has been reviewed by a minimum of 15 publications.
DLC/Expansions are included
Re-releases that received a Metacritic Must-Play are mentioned under the original game unless the original did not receive a Metacritic Must-Play then the re-release would be featured.
Collections are excluded.
DLC/Expansions are included
Re-releases that received a Metacritic Must-Play are mentioned under the original game unless the original did not receive a Metacritic Must-Play then the re-release would be featured.
Collections are excluded.
301 Games
Virtua Fighter 4: Evolution also received a Metacritic Must-Play
Shadow of the Colossus (2018) also received a Metacritic Must-Play
Portal: Still Alive also received a Metacritic Must-Play
ramonzer0
3 months ago
Did want to note one thing though: Marvel VS Capcom 2 still has a Must-Play Tag on there via the Dreamcast release - the site has it if you wanted to double check.