Games where there is a "dark" version of the protag

They're just like me fr fr

Some clarifications because this list has gotten a lot of attention.
- Shadow versions of a character count especially if they're supposed to be "the dark version of you" or "your inner darkness personified"
- Foils don't count since they are a completely separate person from the protagonist. This counts for entities that were created by an antagonist to counter the protagonist (Examples: Jeanne from Bayonetta, Metal Sonic, Shadow, Crunch Bandicoot)
- Shadow versions of NPCs don't count but I'll count shadow versions of party members
- I try to verify everything I add to this list so if there's something I can't verify I might ask for clarification
Thanks!

Mr. Scratch
Mimic Tear
Doppelgangers for 3 of the selectable protagonists
Cosmic Clone
Cosmic Clones
Badeline
Dark Samus
Herobrine
Memory of Alessa
Ryu Doppelganger
Dark Pit (AKA Black Pit in Japan lol)
Every party member has a "shadow" form
Dark Rayman
Shadow Maya, Yukino, Tatsuya, Lisa, and Eikichi
Infernal Shadow
Blood Falcon
Every player fights a shadow version of themselves in the "story" mode
Doppelganger @ Shivering Isles DLC
Dark Jak
Shadow Mario
Doppelgänger
Antisora
The Other Dude
Doppelgängers
Doppelgänger
Akane's Joker
Dark Jak
Cosmic Clones
The Impostor
Doppelgänger
Mona and Lisa
Almost every character has a shadow form (this is the same for ultimax as well)
Mona and Lisa
Doppleganger
Evil Maxwell
Future Peter Parker
Late game boss (slight spoilers I guess?)
Inner Weakness
Shadow Ray
Doppelgänger
Doppelgänger
Dark Links in the Den of Trials
Mirror Fights
Shadow Ray

39 Comments


6 months ago

@TimAlien There are more MegaTen games with doppelgangers and evil clones.
SMT II
SMT if...
SMT Devil Summoner
Soul Hackers
Raidou vs. King Abaddon
Soul Hackers 2
Giten Megami Tensei
Megami Ibunroku Persona

There's also Street Fighter Alpha 2/3, IV, and USFII's Evil Ryu.

Dragon Ball Xenoverse has a DLC that lets you fight your own CaC's ego.

I don't know if you'll bother adding all of this tho lol

6 months ago

For Spider-man, Peter Parker is also the antagonist
https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Peter_Parker_(2099)_(Earth-TRN199)
For Tales of Bersaria, maybe fit's less as I forgot that someone possesses the original.

Also Alan Wake ii still has Mr.Scratch

6 months ago

@stale_cheeto Love all these suggestions! I'm having a hard time finding info on the Xenoverse one to verify it so I'll leave it out for now but I've added all the other ones.
@bitterbatterdog That makes a lot more sense! Thanks for the clarification and for catching Alan Wake II!

6 months ago

@TimAlien This video gives context for the Xenoverse DLC. https://youtu.be/F476CicB6RA?t=9m54s

When you train with the Elder Kai, he notices that the protagonist's ego has a "weakness," so they have to fight it in order to cleanse their mind from impure thoughts.

6 months ago

@stale_cheeto Thanks for the clarification! I think that fits perfectly. Xenoverse added!

2 months ago

dont know if youre still updating this, but fear & hunger 2: termina has doppelgangers for three of the eight selectable protagonists

2 months ago

@putaslayer The lists will never die

1 month ago

Infernal Eikon & Infernal Shadow from FF16. The fight has quite a few reveals before the fight, so video linked is when the Infernal Eikon fight starts, but ik they yap during cutscenes mid-fight as well so viewer discretion adviced ig.

https://youtu.be/Fx4SAcsYulA?t=341

1 month ago

@wreith Noyce


Last updated: