Games where there is a "dark" version of the protag

They're just like me fr fr

Some clarifications because this list has gotten a lot of attention.
- Shadow versions of a character count especially if they're supposed to be "the dark version of you" or "your inner darkness personified"
- Foils don't count since they are a completely separate person from the protagonist. This counts for entities that were created by an antagonist to counter the protagonist (Examples: Jeanne from Bayonetta, Metal Sonic, Shadow, Crunch Bandicoot)
- Shadow versions of NPCs don't count but I'll count shadow versions of party members
- I try to verify everything I add to this list so if there's something I can't verify I might ask for clarification
Thanks!

Herobrine
Mimic Tear
Badeline
Cosmic Clone
Every player fights a shadow version of themselves in the "story" mode
Cosmic Clones
Shadow Mario
Cosmic Clones
Doppelgängers
Antisora
Dark Rayman
Doppelganger @ Shivering Isles DLC
Dark Samus
Akane's Joker
Infernal Shadow
Memory of Alessa
Doppelgänger
Dark Pit (AKA Black Pit in Japan lol)
Doppelgänger
Every party member has a "shadow" form
Mr. Scratch
Inner Weakness
Dark Jak
Doppleganger
Doppelgänger
Dark Jak
Evil Maxwell
Shadow Maya, Yukino, Tatsuya, Lisa, and Eikichi
Mona and Lisa
Dark Links in the Den of Trials
Mirror Fights
Blood Falcon
Almost every character has a shadow form (this is the same for ultimax as well)
Doppelgänger
Ryu Doppelganger
Mona and Lisa
The Impostor
Future Peter Parker
Doppelgänger
Doppelgangers for 3 of the selectable protagonists
Late game boss (slight spoilers I guess?)
The Other Dude
Shadow Ray
Shadow Ray

39 Comments


6 months ago

@TimAlien There are more MegaTen games with doppelgangers and evil clones.
SMT II
SMT if...
SMT Devil Summoner
Soul Hackers
Raidou vs. King Abaddon
Soul Hackers 2
Giten Megami Tensei
Megami Ibunroku Persona

There's also Street Fighter Alpha 2/3, IV, and USFII's Evil Ryu.

Dragon Ball Xenoverse has a DLC that lets you fight your own CaC's ego.

I don't know if you'll bother adding all of this tho lol

6 months ago

For Spider-man, Peter Parker is also the antagonist
https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Peter_Parker_(2099)_(Earth-TRN199)
For Tales of Bersaria, maybe fit's less as I forgot that someone possesses the original.

Also Alan Wake ii still has Mr.Scratch

6 months ago

@stale_cheeto Love all these suggestions! I'm having a hard time finding info on the Xenoverse one to verify it so I'll leave it out for now but I've added all the other ones.
@bitterbatterdog That makes a lot more sense! Thanks for the clarification and for catching Alan Wake II!

6 months ago

@TimAlien This video gives context for the Xenoverse DLC. https://youtu.be/F476CicB6RA?t=9m54s

When you train with the Elder Kai, he notices that the protagonist's ego has a "weakness," so they have to fight it in order to cleanse their mind from impure thoughts.

6 months ago

@stale_cheeto Thanks for the clarification! I think that fits perfectly. Xenoverse added!

1 month ago

dont know if youre still updating this, but fear & hunger 2: termina has doppelgangers for three of the eight selectable protagonists

1 month ago

@putaslayer The lists will never die

1 month ago

Infernal Eikon & Infernal Shadow from FF16. The fight has quite a few reveals before the fight, so video linked is when the Infernal Eikon fight starts, but ik they yap during cutscenes mid-fight as well so viewer discretion adviced ig.

https://youtu.be/Fx4SAcsYulA?t=341

1 month ago

@wreith Noyce


Last updated: